While integration sounds innovative, the real challenge is practicality. Unless institutions have the infrastructure and faculty to teach both systems thoroughly, such courses may do more harm than good. A cautious, evidence-based approach is needed.
Yeah here we mostly the topic is about the two dual medical degree,which each one has its own pross and cons. And it’s actually confuses the students and mostly it’s need an practical experience and also the theoretical experience on hand .and this increases the competence between the medicines and each one has its own criteria to cure the disease like with allopathic medicine or even the ayurved medicine and I agree with the both .
I feel here that merging would not be confused with blindly following to do what Ayurveda says. Say for the next five years, the government should run a research drive and examine all the claimed benefits of ayurvedic medicine. The ones which are proved beneficial , there is no harm in accepting that. The only concern of the doctors of evidence based modern medicine is that Ayurveda is not research backed , just a fluff.
If the results prove the medications prescribed in Ayurveda to be good to be applied then why not. No one is saying to learn mantras and chants and make jadi butis that is the misconceptions seated in minds of people. Integration means combining the knowledge that at the end proves to be beneficial for the humankind.
1 Like
There is no mixing of any so-called entirely different fields, as the basics are the same; it needs to connect and bridge knowledge. Knowledge is not a waste; it needs to have connective dots so that you can get more clarity and move toward the journey of understanding to bring more clear and innovative solutions. Expand your horizons of knowledge and sight, not accepting the invaders’ mindset up which had differed based on considering superiority. We Indians have to come out of the slave thought process, or to be boss or leader of others, all are one, we should focus on the soul of the services with compassion and love.
The dual medical degree opens new horizons, but raises concerns about academic overload and practical integration of two diverse systems. Anyhow the load a medical student already have we can watch through the negative impacts they have on them. Combining MBBS and BAMS may create holistic doctors, yet the challenge lies in maintaining depth, quality, and balanced training. While innovative, the dual degree risks overwhelming students—quality education must not be sacrificed for speed or experimentation.
As of now, we are not properly backed up in terms of teaching and evaluation in medical colleges. Bringing in a new concept of Medicine would perplex the educators as well as students. Integrating two different methods of treatment is not a bad idea in its own but responsibility of it’s application cannot be burdened upon students without any experience. If it is to be implemented then Consultants and Professors with good experience should be trained and permitted to practice it.
1 Like
Yes what you said is true as different paths and different ways of seeing and using of medicine creates unnecessary chaos .so let it be separate
i do not think mixopathy works because it cause burden on the student mmbs is a tough deggre and you need so much patience. furthermore the method of treatment are different in allopathy and homeopathy its difficult to bring synergistic effect.
The patient will be confused
Because MBBS student prescribe some medicine for Hypertension
Mixopathy student prescribe some medicine so the level of risk is high
We all know that patient getting good experience while treatment
Allopathy is new generation medicinal system it has a lot of medicinal benifit and it’s onset of action is fast but it has major side effect.
The second is Ayurveda it is a traditional medicinal system it has slow treatment but it does not occur any side effect or adverse effect .
So as my openion the mixopathy is creat a new medical system which reduce allopathy side effect or increase patient safety .
1 Like
Mixopathy poses serious risks to medical education and patient care. By trying to merge MBBS and BAMS into a single short course, it may produce graduates with superficial understanding of both systems but causes confusion among practitioners and patients. Strengthening existing medical infrastructure is a safer, more effective approach in my point of view.
It is true. You can never know how the body will react. Just allopathy already as so many variables that us as doctors can’t predict. Imaging adding another set of variables. Even the best doctors in the world can’t predict what can go wrong!
1 Like
It is very much true. As there is a saying “ Jack of all trades is a master of none”, combining two different things will not the students master any speciality. Making experiments in such critical areas like healthcare is not acceptable. Ultimately there would be a vast decline in the quality of care administered to the public. It also stops the progression of advanced technology application to the medical field.
1 Like
I think Mixology is a boon to healthcare industry,It’s not two entirely different system mixed together their Basics are similar.The knowledge never goes wasted.If the curriculum is strong enough to balence both knowledge of Ayurveda and Modern.Though it is having Cons, the Pros are more significant and numerous than the drawbacks.
PROS:
1.Emergence of new Pharmaceutical drugs.The chemical constituents of Ayurvedic Medicine can be taken and transformed into fast acting allopathic medicine.
2.Ayurveda is lagging in Research field than Allopathy so there is a possibility of making Ayurveda more evidence based.
3.The integrated System gives chance for each Allopaths to treat all Chronic autoimmune diseases and lifestyle disorder effectively rather than giving symptomatic relief and Chance for each Ayurvedic doctor to treat emergency cases effectively.
4.Its giving more clarity to the doctors rather than confusion like which is curable they can go with holistic approach and for incurable they can go with modern approach.
5.It pushes the patients towards healthier lifestyle rather than depends on pills for living.
At the end of the day,It’s all depends on the knowledge and approach of doctors
1 Like
There should be no room for such trial and errors when it comes to healthcare. This feels like mixing up oil and water two different things that’s never going to blend together. The focus should be on improvising what we have today for a better future. When it comes to healthcare there are many more questions yet to be answered why focusing on something useless when we have more to do.
Mixopathy,will be having one major drawback that in Allopathy the dosage form ingredient’s quality does not vary so much, batch to batch as they are produced from labs. In Ayurved medicine the dosage form ingredients are made from natural sources,that’s why the quality may change batch to batch. It will create one issue.
The concept of Mixopathy addresses various issues, as combining two different studies with distinct solutions for the same problem can lead to confusing outcomes, and people are not in favor of experiments.
Mixopathy is really hard to the future doctors. They will obtain not only the dual degree knowledge along with hypertenstion, stress and mental impatience. They even stuck at one point when put lots of load to that young age. This will make serious impact on student community. They will confuse what they choose and where they all are.
Dual degree gonna be a concern making medical field more saturated and mostly patient face lot of problems because of mixopathy which creates a great chaos
This is only going to create chaos…it’s better if they remain seperated so that each of the professions focus and work at their best