Over-Medicalization of Childbirth: Are Too Many C-Sections Being Performed?

General
, , , ,
1

Rising C-Section Rates Globally

Over the past few decades, the rate of Caesarean sections (C-sections) has been increasing steadily around the world. According to WHO data, more than 1 in 5 births (about 21 %) are currently by C-section globally, a figure set to increase to nearly 29 % by the year 2030 if current trends continue. The majority of countries far exceed the ideal rate as defined by health experts, at about 10-15 % of births.

When C-Sections are Medically Necessary

C-sections are lifesavers in most circumstances — for example, during fetal distress, abnormal presentation (breech), obstructed labor, placenta previa, or other risk to mother or baby’s health. In such circumstances, surgical delivery reduces risk of morbidity and mortality of both mother and infant.

Risks of Unnecessary C-Sections

When performed without medical necessity, C-sections bring additional risk: increased risk of infection, bleeding, blood clots, increased maternal recovery time, and possible complications in future pregnancies. Elective C-section infants also have an increased risk of respiratory distress and other short-term health problems. The cost is also significant — to families and also to health systems.

Drivers Behind Overuse

Several non-medical reasons appear to be driving rising C-section rates: desire for particular scheduling predictability; concern regarding pain or trouble with vaginal birth; pecuniary incentives in the private sector; family and societal culture expectations; and concerns by providers regarding liability. Wealth, education, use of private hospitals, and media exposure are predictors of non-medically indicated C-sections in high-eve C-section communities.

What Can Be Done?

WHO guidelines recommend non-clinical interventions to reduce unnecessary C-sections: better antenatal counselling; informing women in full; using classifications (e.g. Robson classification) to track and audit C-section rates; second opinions before surgery; and reforming payment models in an effort to reduce financial incentives for surgical birth.

Should the choice for a C-section (in low-risk pregnancies) be limited to strictly medical indications, even if the mother prefers it for non-medical reasons?

MBH/PS

14 Likes
2

The rising rates of C-sections worldwide raise important concerns. While this procedure can be lifesaving in emergencies, its overuse without clear medical indication may expose both mother and baby to unnecessary risks. Promoting evidence-based obstetric care, empowering women with informed choices, and strengthening midwifery and natural birthing practices can help strike the right balance between safety and over-medicalization.

2 Likes
3

After reading this post, I can certainly understand the urgent need to balance medical necessity by reducing unnecessary C-sections.

1 Like
4

I feel c section medical advancement. This way of childbirth is opted by mother who cannot endure pain or if a medical conditions need c section only .

1 Like
5

I don’t know whether I’m right or wrong but some doctors unnecessarily advice c-section even when there is mild complications. I think some consideration should be given to the case, to the mother before c-section.

1 Like
6

Informative knowledge

7

C Section is so common now a day without any consideration , this is recommend even whete the case is not so much sincere.

And this post make me informative.about c section and the necessity

1 Like
8

I think the life style change is the total cost our lives. In early time women’s are so strong by physically and mentally due to their food habbits and works. Nowadays we didn’t follow the proper food chart and become so weak especially in pregnancy causing too much vitamin and mineral deficiency without physical activity it wil leads to c-section

2 Likes
9

This is an important question While respecting a mother’s autonomy is essential, medical professionals also have the responsibility to prioritize safety For low-risk pregnancies C sections should ideally be reserved for medical indications, since unnecessary surgery increases risks for both mother and child. Strengthening antenatal counselling and ensuring mothers are fully informed may help in balancing personal choice with evidence-based medical practice.

1 Like
10

Limiting C-sections to medical necessity helps protect maternal and infant health by avoiding preventable risks. Still, when a mother fully understands those risks, her preference should be respected.

1 Like
11

Absolutely!! C-sections should be limited to only medical indications. It puts unnecessary stress on the mother and increases risk of post-op complications.

1 Like
12

Unnecessary C-sections will surely risk the health and sufferings of the mother. An article like this should be available to spread information to pregnant women.

1 Like
13

Yes , the unnecessary preference for C-sections now-a-days has been increased,which should be given a thought by both husband and wife . As in today’s era the immunity and strength a mother should hold for natural deliveries are much more less and that’s y they r opting for c -sections more over the natural process . So the though for elective procedures should be decided by the couple as a whole and this I am mentioning for the support that should be given by the husband to his wife to overcome the fear of natural births.

Secondly , as per the guidelines , yes, there should be restrictions but not strictly though to adhere going beyond the patient’s choice . We can try and counsel the most till the whole of pregnancy to the mother about the pros and cons of both , the natural and the c-section deliveries. But still if she opts for C-section unnecessarily of the guidelines,then we should respect her decision as this can be a matter of trust and support in between a doctor and the patient .

1 Like
15

Although C-sections save lives, there are risks associated with their overuse. Reversing this trend requires empowering women with evidence-based care and informed choices.

1 Like
16

The advancements in obstetric care, particularly cesarean section, have been very useful in preventing maternal deaths and other complications. However, the incidence of pregnancy-related conditions such as PIH and GDM—often associated with macrosomia—has increased compared to older records. That may be because to life style changes as some others also mentioned this above .

These advancements have also made cesarean sections readily available even in semi-urban hospitals. This, in turn, may be one of the reasons for their overutilization in inappropriate situations.But ,inorder to avoid the short term complications - pain due to normal vaginal delivery (mainly) ,they- patients choose a c-section which may cause the future complications.

1 Like
17

Absolutely, much needed awareness for people .

18

Yes, the limiting the choice of C-section to medical risk group of pregnancies is a great option. Many unnecessary complications can be avoided this way.